spacer
Donate Image

Your Donations Count Donate Graphicat the Westside Observer!

Watchdog at the Courthouse

Who’s Keeping Score on Local Judges on the March 2024 ballot?

Informing Voters about Our Judges is Essential for Our Democracy

•••••••••• September 21, 2023 ••••••••••

Over our careers and lifetimes, we are called upon to make decisions that affect our lives and futures and those of loved ones and our communities. Access to vital information and committing to ground our decisions in fact, law and good judgment are essential. I advocate this as a member of Stop Crime SF. San Francisco voters are entitled to have critical and relevant information about our local judges who may appear on our ballot at the March 2024 election.

That's why I'm helping Stop Crime SF to educate voters about the decisions of our Superior Court judges. Community safety and protection are fundamental responsibilities of the government and all members of our society.

I was surprised to see my former colleague, Berkeley Law School Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, write an OpEd in the Chronicle attacking the Stop Crime SF program. While I greatly respect Dean Chemerinsky, he is profoundly wrong in his outsized criticism of our work to help voters understand the judiciary.

Through judicial elections, California law entrusts its citizens with the power to retain or reject sitting judges. Dean Chemerinsky's approach would deprive voters of important factual information about the decisions of those judges and how they affect our daily lives. We need more light, not less, on the public decisions of judges.

StopCrime SF’s plan to survey defense lawyers and prosecutors who appear before the judges regularly, as well as the judges themselves, will produce unique, informed and balanced insights into our local judicial system. It comes at a time when citizens seek more answers about what is going on in our courts and in the aftermath of the historic recall of former District Attorney Chesa Boudin (recently hired by Dean Chemerinsky at his law school.)

Most significantly, StopCrime SF asks the judges themselves how voters should evaluate judicial records and what information is relevant to their decision to retain judges. StopCrime SF also asks for portions of the questionnaires judges submitted to the governor when they sought appointment to the bench. If the information is important and legitimate for the governor's appointment decision, it is equally valid for voters when they decide whether to retain or reject the judge.

quotes

StopCrime SF asks the judges themselves how voters should evaluate judicial records and what information is relevant to their decision to retain judges. StopCrime SF also asks for portions of the questionnaires judges submitted to the governor when they sought appointment to the bench.”

Dean Chemerinsky asserts that StopCrime SF wants judges to rule in favor of police when there are claims of excessive force or violations of suspects’ constitutional rights. He did so without checking with us. Had he even viewed our website, stopcrimesf.com, he would have read our insistence on “accountability for law enforcement. Police who abuse their power and cause great harm should face consequences.” Our vision for San Francisco is a city where all residents feel safe, where people take responsibility for their crimes, where rehabilitation programs correct harmful behavior, and where jails are reserved for the most dangerous and repeat offenders.

Dean Chemerinsky is free to disagree with our principles, but he is not free to misstate them or condemn our efforts to let the public know what is going on daily in our courtrooms. Judges and the judicial process have been cloaked in secrecy for too long. Judicial proceedings are frequently mind-boggling to all but lawyers and judges. It is no wonder average citizens shudder when they receive a jury duty notice, and crime victims and witnesses too often leave courtrooms with little understanding of what has occurred.  

Dean Chemerinsky acknowledges that voters have a say in judicial elections. StopCrime SF members, with the input of courtroom participants, will publicize factual information about judges and judicial proceedings to equip and empower voters to make informed decisions. In 2020, prior to the last local judicial elections, over 300 attended StopCrime SF's election forum, a clear reflection of the need and hunger for information about our judges. Notwithstanding Dean Chemerinsky’s concern, voters desire and can handle the truth! 

As for his concern about “pressuring” judges, millions of Americans have marched for or against court decisions on women’s reproductive freedoms, freedom to marry, and other matters of societal importance. That’s not pressuring, either. It’s our democratic right to inform and persuade one another.

Dean Chemerinsky admits that “deterrence of crime is most linked to the certainty of prosecution and conviction, which turns on police, prosecutors and courts.” In 2022, San Franciscans spoke loudly and recalled the former District Attorney. On March 5, 2024, voters can make their voices heard in contested judicial races. Through StopCrimeSF’s leadership, voters will be armed with fact-based analysis to cast informed votes and elect judges who will promote justice, public safety and our values as a city.  

StopCrime SF is a grassroots group of San Francisco neighbors from all walks of life who share a genuine concern about the criminal justice system and the well-being of all San Franciscans.

StopCrime SF member John Trasviña is the immediate past Dean of the University of San Francisco School of Law and has served in three Democratic presidential administrations.

September 21, 2023

Have Your Say

More Trending Articles


Removing density controls in western and central SF?

Redevelopment

Mayor’s Upzoning Plan Endangers Our Neighborhoods

by Dennis Antenore

Demolitions, speculations, and displacement are in store if the city moves forward with Breed’s approach.

Check it out
Employee Disparagement

SFPUC’s Employee discontent under Herrera

by Dr. Derek Kerr

Herrera’s team has settled in. The disruptions from the FBI probe and COVID had abated. Employee satisfaction should have improved. It didn’t.

Check it out

Twin Peaks Aerial

Big Changes in Store for Twin Peaks

by Jonathan Farrell

“As it is right now...there is no plan to manage and care for Twin Peaks

Check it out

School Closed

SFUSD Considers School Closures

by Carol Kocivar

No one wants to close schools. Not the communities. Not the school boards. Not administrators and school district personnel..

Read More

Turf a GGP

Phil Ginsburg: Stop poisoning our world

by David Romano

Will Rec and Park be satisfied when every square foot of Golden Gate Park is concrete and artificial turf?

Check it out

Every five years, the EPA determines the success of superfund cleanups

Gantry Crane

New Shipyard Report Confirms: Unsafe for Habitation

by Dr. Ahimsa Porter Sumchai

Take-home message: Cleanup efforts in 15 parcels and sites do not protect residents from hazardous substances, pollutants, and contaminants emanating from the dirty base

Check it out

© 2023 Westside San Francisco Media. No portion of the articles or artwork may be republished without expressed consent. Legal disclaimer.