Donate Image

Your Donations Count Donate Graphicat the Westside Observer!

Ethnic diversity at Lowell High

Lowell Admissions: Will changing high school admission policies fix the achievement gap?

•••••••••• January 26, 2023 ••••••••••

Everyone seems to have their own version of the truth. The ongoing controversy over admission to San Francisco’s Lowell high school is a good example. This debate has been long on opinion and short on facts.

The issue is heating up AGAIN. This spring, the SFUSD high school task force is scheduled to present recommendations on future admission policies to the Superintendent.


Let’s take a look at some of those arguments and match them against the data for San Francisco.


The real issue is not selective admissions. It is the failure to educate all our children well in the early grades.”

Ethnic Diversity

Is Lowell High school less diverse than other San Francisco high schools?  The short answer is “no”.  

California tracks schools using a diversity index that reflects how evenly distributed students are among the race/ethnicity categories. The more evenly distributed the student body, the higher the number. A school where all of the students are the same ethnicity would have an index of 0.

The chart below shows how Lowell’s diversity index score has steadily increased over the last two decades.

Ethnic Diversity chart

This dramatic increase is the result of an admission policy specifically designed to increase diversity. About 70 per cent of students are admitted on grades and test scores alone. Another 30 percent are admitted using additional criteria, such as the ability to overcome hardships, socioeconomic status, and extenuating circumstances. Schools are prohibited from using race as a criterion.

How does Lowell’s ethnic diversity compare to other high schools?

Lowell is more diverse than most other high schools. The chart below ranks SFUSD high schools and shows that Lowell’s diversity has increased more than all other schools but one.

SF Diversity Chart

Should City or school district demographics be used?

One question to ponder is whether high school diversity should be measured against the diversity of the city or the diversity of the school district. They are very different,

Lowell serves over 35% low-income students. The district serves about 50% low income. Should Lowell be considered “elite” because it serves less low-income students than the district? San Francisco has about 10% of low-income children. Using City data, should Lowell be viewed as serving large numbers of low-income students?

Forty percent of San Francisco’s children are white. Should Lowell —with about 17 % white students—be considered a “white privilege” school because it serves a higher percentage of white students than the school district (13%)? Or should it be considered a school that serves predominantly minority students?

There are several major differences between the child population in the City and the students in the school district and at Lowell. Compared to the City:

  1. Child poverty is much higher in the district and at Lowell
  2. The white student population is much lower in the district and at Lowell.
  3. The Asian population is significantly higher at Lowell.
  4. The Black and African American population is low in the city, in the district and even lower at Lowell.

About 30 percent of San Francisco students do not attend public schools. That’s why there is such a discrepancy between the number of white students in the school district versus the city.

Lowell Admissions Chart

Who gets into Lowell and why?

Under a selective admission policy, students are admitted based primarily on their academic performance.

Under a lottery, students are admitted by chance. This results in admitting some students who are not proficient and rejecting some students who are.

Look at the charts below.  They show SFUSD 8th-grade proficiency levels for Asians and Black and African Americans. Both groups have faced historic discrimination. 

Black and African American Proficiency 8th-grade proficiency

Proficiency Chart

Asian Proficiency — 8th-grade

Proficiency Chart 2

The data shows most Black and African American students are not ready for a high school designed for high performing students. Most Asian students are ready.

Now, make an educated guess.

  1. Under a selective admission policy, which group will have a higher percent of high performing students admitted?
  2. Using a lottery, which group will have the highest percent of low performing students accepted?
  3. Using a lottery, which group will have the highest percent of high performing students rejected?
  4. Which policy will result in the highest number of students failing?

You got it. Under a lottery, a higher percentage of low performing students will be admitted. The lottery also results in a higher percentage of high performing students rejected.

Does that change your view of which policy is most equitable?

If we all want equity, are we looking at the real issue?

The real issue is not selective admissions. It is the failure to educate all our children well in the early grades.

Carol Kocivar is a children’s advocate and lives in the Westside. Feedback:

January 26, 2023

Have Your Say

More Trending Articles

Senior Call In

Behind Peskin’s Dark Maneuver

Sudden Death of Remote Public Comment

Patrick Monette-Shaw

It effectively punishes hundreds, if not thousands, who want to participate in our local government. Even worse, it will force those who have disabilities to disclose their special needs. Or face the burden of traveling to City Hall.

Check it out

Popular bay view

New Playgrounds for the Wealthy from Diverted Clean-up Funds

by Laurent Philonenko, Erin Roach & Evelyn Graham

Rec and Park’s plot to build a new boat harbor will close the Bay views and access from Marina Green.

Check it out

Star of India

Three Consecutive Burglaries at Star of India

by Jonathan Farrell

It cost Star of India nearly $5,000 to replace the glass doors and to put new bars up.

Check it out

London Breed

District Elections, London Breed & the Housing Exageration

by Quentin Kopp

Construction of new housing? I’ve concluded from present vacancies and dispirited new home construction the matter is extravagantly exaggerated by City Hall politicians and local media.

Check it out

Streets, sidewalks and roofs of cities all absorb heat during the day

SF at Sunset

Signs of Climate Change Beneath Our Feet

by Glenn Rogers

Unlike the temperature in the atmosphere — ground temperatures become increasingly warmer over time a recent study found

Check it out

Neighbor Power

Bench at Shaw&s Candy and Ice cream

Support for Shaw’s Candy Victims as New Evidence Emerges

by Thomas K. Pendergast

It is alleged that on the afternoon of September 27th, Janda was sitting on the bench in front of her ice cream shop.

Check it out

© 2023 Westside San Francisco Media. No portion of the articles or artwork may be republished without expressed consent. Legal disclaimer.