Donate Image

Your Donations Count Donate Graphicat the Westside Observer!

Ahimsa at Rally
Residents of Bayview protest dangerous clean-up operations of superfund site

The Dirt at Hunters Point

"There are three classes of people: those who see, those who see when they are shown…and those who do not see. —Leonardo da Vinci

•••••••••• August, 2023 ••••••••••

You might have thought the discussion was about the meticulous oversight of gold ore … not about moving dirt at a radiation-contaminated Federal Superfund site!

Superfund Site
Superfund site map shows "Cleaned-up" parcels that have been transferred to the City (in yellow) and those undergoing clean-up (in pink). The red line indicates the original shoreline.

On August 15, 2023, the Health Commission met to approve amendments to the Article 31 Health Code ordinance to streamline and make accepting the dirty transfer of properties at the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard easier.

The Health Commission originally adopted Article 31 on December 12, 2004. The meeting minutes document my dissent on the grounds that Article 31 serves as a law that codifies the Health Department’s conflict of interest with the shipyard’s master developers Lennar & Five Point Holdings.

Road Closed in Hunters Point
Road closed in Hunters Point Photo courtesy of SF Bayview

The cruel irony of Article 31 is that the Health Code offers no direct services to populations whose health is compromised by the dirty development of the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard. Article 31 relegated the Health Department to a "wing" of the Redevelopment Agency and city planning and established the San Francisco Department of Public Health as a revenue-generating enterprise department of city government.

According to the memo dated August 15, 2023, from Patrick Fosdahl, Director of Environmental Health to Health Commissioners on the subject: Revisions to Health Code Article 31 Regulations:

Article 31 Health Code
Patrick Fosdahl is DPH’s Director of Environmental Health and Article 31 Regulations are managed by Bill Chen

“The Hunters Point Naval Shipyard is a Federal Superfund Site … As parcels are cleaned, they are transferred to the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure (OCII). OCII has development agreements with for-profit developers, i.e. Lennar and, in the future, Fivepoint for the project including the infrastructure, parks and residences that include below-maret-rate-units. OCII also has agreements with 100% affordable housing developers for particular blocks.“

Chain-link fencing is not a dust barrier
Bayview profile
The Bayview remains predomonintly African-American
hospitalizations Bayview
High Cancer rates in Bayview Women
Bayview cleanup
Cleanup of radioactive dirt seems to have no safety precautions

The publicly posted memo fails to state that revenue generated by earth-moving activities on a Superfund property assigned an EPA Hazard Score of 80 (50 being average) flows via the for-profit developers through OCII to the San Francisco Department of Public Health.

Cancer Cluster
Cluster of breast cancer cases encircle the base (half-mile perimeter)

The principal moral, ethical and medico-legal dilemma evident in the Health Commission's reaffirming vote to streamline the transfer of the shipyard's most heavily contaminated waste is that the steady and potentially growing revenue stream generated by the adoption of Article 31 of the Health Code is its blinding influence on the Health Department's principle mission: to protect public health!

unmasked worker
Workers within the toxic clean-up zone labor unprotected against poisening
Neighbors of Hunters Point
Bayview residents wear
masks hoping to reduce
dust inhalation

In the echoing words of Leonardo da Vinci: There are three classes of people. The second class is those who see when they are shown. The Health Department archives vast epidemiological evidence of human exposures to toxic pollutants in the city's heavily industrialized southeast sector it does not see when shown!

Dr. Ahimsa Sumchai is a climate activist living on the Westside.

August 2023

Have Your Say

More Trending Articles

Wolf in sheep's clothing

Sowing Discord

by Julie Pitta

Big money ‘neighborhood’ groups step up their campaign of take-over tactics in 2024 elections.

Check it out

Popular bay view

Say NO to expanding yacht harbors for the wealthy

by Evelyn Graham

Rec and Park’s plan expands access for the privileged few bupkis for the rest of us.

Check it out

New proposed site

New proposed location for Ocean View Library is ideal

by Glenn Rogers

Few were surprised when Supervisor Safai learned the library was not to be built in the Greenbelt — he feared the worst. No library at all.Since 2023, the Library Commission has been considering 466 Randolph Street, where the I.T. Bookman Community Center and the Pilgrim Community Church are located.

Check it out

SF from Alameda Point

San Francisco. In Alameda? Wait, what?

by David Osgood

When the runways for the Alameda Naval Air Station were extended out into the bay—using dredged bay fill, the same way Treasure Island was created — they crossed over the city line. The federal government apparently didn't know or care.

Read More ...

Man in Wheelchair

San Franciscans need nursing home care

Will Laguna Honda Admissions Start Soon?

by Dr. Teresa Palmer

The survey attests to a quality of care that is higher than in for-profit private nursing homes. But there are ongoing problems.

Read More


parking tickets for RVs on Winston

RV residents on Winston Drive face uncertain future

by Thomas K. Pendergast

A four-hour parking limit is going to make things even more difficult for RV residents.

Check it out

© 2023 Westside San Francisco Media. No portion of the articles or artwork may be republished without expressed consent. Legal disclaimer.